Though the age-old question remains unanswered (you know, the chicken-egg thing), it is certain that urban agriculture will not be expanding in St. Louis any time soon.
The Board of Aldermen soundly rejected Scott Ogilvie's measure on Friday that would have boosted the number of backyard chickens allowed from four to eight, and let residents keep sheep, goats and emu on larger lots.
Supporters took the defeat mostly in stride
Chicken bill got slaughtered on the floor.
— Cara Spencer (@CaraSpencerSTL) March 4, 2016
.@shanecohn we were Flock Blocked.
— Cara Spencer (@CaraSpencerSTL) March 4, 2016
Roll call
- Ayes - Aldermen Ingrassia, Green, Spencer, Ogilvie, Cohn, Krewson
- Nays - Aldermen Tyus, Flowers, Bosley, Hubbard, Conway, Ortmann, Villa, Arnowitz, Murphy, Howard, Baringer, Roddy, Davis, Vaccaro, Carter
- Present - Alderman Kennedy
- Did note vote - Aldermen Moore, Coatar, Vollmer, French, Boyd, Williamson, Pres Reed.
"We've gone too far in this direction of saying food comes from some other place," Ogilvie said. "I think some nice things happen when you understand that whole process of where food is coming from."
But 19th Ward Alderman Marlene Davis and many of her colleagues wanted residents to be able to say yes or no to more livestock.
"We represent them. They choose to live in the city, they choose to have ownership in the city, they choose to pay taxes in the city, and that's the least I can do to protect them," she said.
The debate lasted nearly two hours.
Cluckin' crazy! https://t.co/Lg8ZOClzJJ
— Martina Johnson (@MartinaEvaJ) March 4, 2016
Sigh. It's like a Parks and Rec episode at the STL BOA today. https://t.co/wMvD88uBjB
— TC (@tchopstl_) March 4, 2016
To no one's surprise, Alderman Tom Villa, of the 11th Ward, posed the question everyone wanted answered.
Livestock-based tongue twisters became a thing.
. @rlippmann I have my goat guy on hold until the outcome. Gotta get the call in quick before all the good goats get got. #BoA #STL
— Kevin Barbeau (@YASTLBlog) March 4, 2016
@rlippmann good golly I'm gobsmacked by the goat gossip
— STLrainbow (@stlrainbow) March 4, 2016
@AnnieRiceStL @andrewarkills @rlippmann good grief; galling gentrification goats!
— STLrainbow (@stlrainbow) March 4, 2016
Lobbyists for the Associated General Contractors and the realtors had some fun with memes.
#BOA is now about at 1hr and 37 minutes in. #BOA pic.twitter.com/SwlD859q5Q
— Anthony Lancia (@AnthonyLancia) March 4, 2016
Emusing debate today but no Emus allowed in STL City #STLBOA pic.twitter.com/dbdHL82yHK
— Martina Johnson (@MartinaEvaJ) March 4, 2016
At least one St. Louis resident had gotten a little ahead of himself.
Damn it what am I going to do with my goat now https://t.co/K5512B6c8r
— Steve Oslica (@steveoslica) March 4, 2016
And one alderman apparently got inspired by all the poultry-based discussion.
About to have my favorite kind of city chicken: FRIED at @byrdbarrelstl pic.twitter.com/rRIAZs31w9
— Cara Spencer (@CaraSpencerSTL) March 4, 2016